Shields Mott Blog

ESI: The Odyssey — Part 1: Know Your Hash Value

The very nature of electronic evidence poses numerous, unique challenges to the discovery process and the admission of electronic evidence. ESI, like any information, is discoverable in litigation, but one of the things that makes ESI different is its sheer volume. The vast majority of newly produced information is created and stored electronically. When you combine this with the relative affordability of cloud storage, a staggering number of electronic documents are being created and stored, even by small business clients. Thus, discovery in litigation, even in cases in which the amount of controversy is relatively modest, can embrace huge quantities of data. [Read More…]

Material Suppliers – – Maybe the 75-day notice is not required?

On August 6, 2018 the Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal held that a materialman who failed to provide notice per La. R.S. 38:2242(F) could still pursue a claim against the general contractor and the surety on the payment bond on a public works project pursuant to La. R.S. 38:2247.  In doing so, the First Circuit has arguably recognized that the 75-day notice set forth in La. R.S. 38:2242(F) is no longer required in order for a materialman to assert a claim against a public works payment bond under the Louisiana Public Works Act. [Read More…]

School Board Must Pay Retainage Regardless Of Liquidated Damages Claim. And, Soon Public Entities May Have to Pay Interest On The Retainage Too!

Louisiana Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals (“Court”) held that a public entity, the Orleans Parish School Board (“School Board”), had to promptly make the final payment of retainage to a Public Works contractor, Woodrow Wilson Construction, LLC (“Woodrow”), despite the fact that the School Board claimed it had a right to withhold liquidated damages from Woodrow per their contract (“Contract”). [Read More…]

Shields Mott Win – Construction Managers can now be liable to Contractors

On March 9, 2018 the Louisiana Supreme Court denied Jacobs Project Management Co./CRSS Consortium (“Jacobs”) writ of certiorari regarding the Louisiana Court of Appeals, First Circuit December 6, 2017, decision in the case.  In doing so, the Louisiana Supreme Court has arguably blessed the concept that contractors have a right of action against construction/project managers even through no contractual relationship exists between a contractor and a construction/project manager. [Read More…]

Houston, We Have a Problem: Could Legal Codes, Land Use Regulations, and Zoning Requirements Blunted Harvey’s Devastation?

Hurricane Harvey dumped more than twenty-seven trillion gallons of rain over Texas and Louisiana in six days. As of October 13, 2017, at least eighty-eight fatalities had been confirmed, most of which were drownings. Many locations in the Houston metropolitan area observed between thirty and fifty inches of precipitation; more than Houston usually receives in a year. [Read More…]

AIA’s Latest Green Building Document: E204-2017 – Sustainable Projects Exhibit

This spring, the AIA unveiled the latest updates to its core set of documents and added the E204-2017 as an exhibit that can be used on any project and added to most AIA contracts to address the risks and responsibilities associated with sustainable design and construction services. Proponents/authors of the exhibit argue that it can add “big value to your project on five unique ways. Also, another commentator calls the E204-2017 a “game changer.” So does the E204-2017 live up to the hype? [Read More…]